The Cole Papers
Talk of the floor (clockwise from the upper left): At Macworld Expo, Apple presented its latest theories on the OS X architecture, which layers the Aqua user interface on top of the programming interfaces. Those are then put on top of the graphics-enabling technologies with the result on top of the UNIX kernel. MicroNet's SAN cube looks like a little brother to the G4 and stores 70-gigabytes. For constant USB-based server uptime, Sophisticated Circuits' KickOff restarts a crashed machine.

Appealing new carrots dangled within grasp of Apple legions

SAN FRANCISCO -- Steve Jobs, top gun at Apple Computer Inc., could have walked naked onto the stage for his keynote at the Macworld Expo 2000 held here in January, said he had clothes on, and the faithful would have believed.

The now-permanent chief executive officer (or "iCEO" -- "i" for Internet, so he said) delivered what was basically a sales pitch for the forthcoming new and different Macintosh operating system X (MacOS X), but in the usual Jobsian, reality-distorting way that has become a much anticipated part of these gatherings of confirmed Mac lovers.

This reporter soaked up every reality-distorting byte of information in the lengthy presentation, which ended with Jobs getting a standing ovation. Are these events now the rock-concert equivalent for us aging computer users? I have attended every one of these since 1985; in computer years, that makes me a gray-beard observer.

Moving the Expo so close to the start of the New Year made it a little inconvenient for some, but attendance was not shabby and there were more suppliers than ever in a space that was laid out better than in previous years.

Borrowed from Macworld Expo in New York was registration on a bevy of iMacs, rather than the venue's former focus on PCs -- another sign that Apple is really back. The way of Chairman Steve has, in three short years, made people forget the ponderous pronouncements of former heads Michael Spindler and Gil Amelio, who were media-bashed (perhaps unjustly) into virtual roadkill on the information superhighway.

So what hath Jobs wrought? And what did his keynote on the state of Cupertino, Calif.-based Apple portend, now that his words have had about a month to percolate through the ranks of Mac aficionados?

First, what of the Expo and its exhibitors? Yes, there were some noteworthy new things out there, but this wasn't as hardware-centric a show as it has been in the past, when Apple was getting its product house in order with the introduction of the iMac and iBook. In fact, there was an air of disappointment when the rumor about the introduction of new PowerBooks proved false.

No, this one will be recalled as the Expo where Apple announced its strategy for delivering OS X. (I believe the preferred pronunciation is "oh-ess-ten," but several people in the press room were calling it "oh-ess-ex.")

OS X-tra, read all about it
The new OS X, to be released this summer and to be included with every new Macintosh starting in 2001, is the modern operating system for which power users have been clamoring. Its pre-emptive multitasking and protected memory mean that if numerous applications are running simultaneously and one freezes or crashes, it won't force the entire computer to restart.

Jobs' demo this year was in part an early strike, to allay the fears of long-time Mac users that OS X would be radically different from the interface they have grown accustomed to since its introduction in 1984. That Finder-centered, desktop metaphor might have been inspired by other operating systems, but it was a major leap for the time and made computers much easier for nontechnical people. The system was also easy to maintain.

So OS X has a tall order to fill: do everything Mac users are accustomed to, and more. The demo was certainly successful in showing off its glitz and sizzle, but there are some glitches to overcome.

Here's a brief rundown of OS X, based on Steve Jobs' presentation to his rapt audience:

As almost everyone has heard, the core of the OS, Darwin (see diagram), is SCO Unix-based (the kernel is built on Mach 3.0 and FreeBSD 3.2, and that's as technical as I want to get with UNIX). Next comes the graphics-handling trio: Quartz for 2-D graphics, based on the Adobe Acrobat Portable Document Format; Open GL for 3-D graphics; and QuickTime for multimedia. For compatibility, OS X will be able to run three kinds of applications: the classic Macintosh programs (which won't be able to take advantage of any of the improvements in protected memory and true multitasking); Carbon applications, modified for use with OS X; and Cocoa programs, whose applications written for OS X will run only on OS X.

Overlaying all is Aqua, the new user interface, which does diddle a bit with the Finder as well as add some spiffy new icons and the translucent look of the iMac to the desktop. Window controls are all in the top left corner, and a Single Window Mode is available to help manage desktop window clutter by keeping everything in one window. Aqua also has a Windows-like dock at the bottom of the screen that can hold just about anything, to alleviate desktop mishmash.

What, then, is the bottom line for organizations that have a good sum of money invested in new hardware and somewhat older software? Will everything have to be upgraded to take full advantage of the new OS?

That's a good question, and the answer isn't immediately evident since the first version of OS X won't begin shipping until summer. The best estimate seems to be that the classic Mac applications can run under OS X, but not with Aqua or the improved memory-management features. The fully OS X-compliant applications should be fine, which is why Apple provided the easier Carbon-izing path for applications last year. It should not be too difficult, at least according to Apple, to get from classic to Carbon and achieve the OS X advantages.

Hardware, however, is another can of worms. It is likely, but not set in stone, that OS X will run only on machines powered by G3 and G4 processors, leaving all the earlier Power PC models (601, 603, 604) stuck on System 9 at best. With G3 or G4 upgrades these old machines might support OS X, but for now the situation is uncertain. However, it is definite that OS X will not run on any of the old Quadras and other 68040-based machines.

By getting its product line in shape, Apple has come a long way from the dozens of flavors of Performas, Newton personal digital assistants, printers and modems that were manufactured at one time bearing the Apple logo. With this iteration of the Macintosh OS, looking both backward and forward becomes a more daunting task. But based on the way the transition to the PowerPC processor was handled, I have every confidence Apple will be able to pull off this most important migration, though not without some problems along the way.

A turn around the floor
Now for a quick Expo 2000 once-around, and some notes on what caught my veteran eyes.

  • A Linux graphics server. San Francisco-based Torque Systems Inc. has put together a high-performance Linux graphics server based on Red Hat Linux, a UNIX variant that has become extremely popular. For $5995, fully installed, the package includes a five-user version of Helios Ethershare for easy Unix-to-Macintosh connectivity. The motherboard sports a 500-megahertz central processing unit ready for dual processors, along with Ultra-scsi2 support. Options include gigabit Ethernet and redundant array of inexpensive disks (Raid) from 100 gigabytes to one terabyte. Small operations should take a look at this.

  • The Palm Pilot competitor. Handspring Inc. of Mountain View, Calif. had a constant crowd surging around its large booth to view the Visor, a competitor to 3Com's Palm Pilot portable digital assistant. The built-in expansion slot and nifty iMac-like colors made it seem cooler than the more staid Palm Pilot. But what really stood out was an accessory: a full-sized keyboard that could be folded up to the size of the Visor. Targus Inc. of Anaheim Calif., sells the Targus Stowaway folding keyboard. With a modem in the expansion slot and a note-taking application, a reporter could carry a veritable bureau-in-a-coat-pocket (see The Cole Papers, May 1999). The only minor drawback was a short space bar, necessary because a regular-sized space bar would have overlapped one of the folding hinges.

  • USB proliferation. A new universal serial bus (USB) device that gives automatic crash recovery to USB Macs was on display at the Sophisticated Circuits Inc. booth. Called Kick-off!, it's a hardware and software package that automatically detects crashes and, with three levels of crash recovery, the Bothell, Wash., company thinks most bases have been covered. The product is based on the successful Apple Desktop Bus (ADB) version, Rebound!

    Many companies were promoting their USB keyboards and mice with several sporting iMac hues, and all looked as though they might provide relief from the strangely inadequate mouse and keyboard standards of the iMac. But an even more promising product came from Iogear of Irvine, Calif.: the MiniView USB, along with the MiniView Mac Macintosh adapter, which allows one keyboard, monitor and mouse to control two to four Macs (even those with ADB ports) or PCs.

  • Digital camera/SuperDisk combo. Imation Enterprises Corp. of Oakdale, Minn., and Panasonic showed the new PalmCam SuperDisk digital camera, the first model (PV-SD4090) in its new SuperDisk line. For those digital photogs who don't want to fiddle with cables, the 120-megabyte SuperDisk camera offers storage of approximately 1500 images per disk in 640-by-480 resolution, or 450 images in 1280-by-960 resolution. There are plenty of SuperDisks out there; at the show Imation announced it had passed the one-million mark in shipments of SuperDisk USB drives for the Macintosh. Floppy drives live!

  • FireWire and Storage Area Networks (SANs). It's bigger than a breadbox, but not by very much. MicroNet Technology Inc. of Irvine, Calif., had a SAN cube in its booth, the first FireWire SAN solution. Using a cube-shaped array of up to six IBM FireWire disk drives that weighs less than 25 pounds, it looks like a little brother to the charcoal-colored Macintosh G4 units. Plug the cube into the built-in FireWire port on a G4, install the software, and one to four users can then access large files at speeds up to 10-times faster than a 100-BaseT Ethernet network. It's $1499 for a 70-gigabyte single-user system

    Want more space? How about a terabyte of storage for $1499? That's what Escient Digital Storage Group of Los Gatos, Calif., had in its booth. Remember when an 80-megabyte hard disk cost more than $1000? This remarkable price is for the PowerFile C220 FireWire DVD/CD changer. It's the only FireWire changer on the market, supports both Mac and Windows and includes client/server management software (Cumulus 5) for both operating systems at no additional cost. Burn, baby, burn those CDs!

  • Backups in SCSI-land. With low-cost FireWire storage solutions proliferating, one might think the old small-computer serial-interface (SCSI) was slipping. Perhaps, but there are still plenty of SCSI devices and ports out there, so it's about time a company such as OnStream Inc. of Longmont, Colo., released a modern, high-speed, high-capacity tape backup system for the Macintosh. It's a tape drive with a 30-gigabyte capacity, certainly enough for today's higher capacity hard drives. The tape cartridges are just $39.95, which amounts to about a dollar a gigabyte. The drive retails for $699. Internal server backup tape drives with 50- and 70-gigabyte capacities are also available. Graphics professionals should jump on this.

    Nearly 500 companies exhibited at the Expo this year, displaying literally hundreds of new products for the Macintosh. Yes indeed, the Mac is back, even though the aisles didn't seem that crowded with either people or booths (perhaps better booth organization overall contributed to this). Certain areas, like the Palm Pilot and Visor booths, as well as usual suspects Apple, Adobe and Microsoft, were demo-ing to big crowds. In an informal survey of other, smaller booths I received plenty of declarations that Expo 2000 was a good, if not very good, show.

    The new stripped-down, toned-up Apple is making investors very happy, and iMacs and iBooks are making a lot of new owners happy. More Macs were sold in the last quarter of 1999 -- 1.35 million -- than in any previous quarter in the Mac's history, Jobs proudly revealed in his keynote pitch.

    Exactly what Jobs hath wrought is a developing story, but not one that Mac mavens are about to put down until several more chapters have played out.

    -- George Powell

    Escient Digital Storage Group,
    (877) 838-3669,
    e-mail: dvdchanger@escient.com;
    Handspring Inc.,
    (650) 230-5000,
    e-mail: info@handspring.com;
    Imation Enterprises Corp.,
    (651) 704-4000,
    e-mail: info@imation.com;
    Iogear,
    (949) 250-1260,
    e-mail: sales@iogear.com;
    MicroNet Technology Inc,
    (949) 543-6100,
    e-mail: info@micronet.com;
    OnStream Inc.,
    (303) 772-9000,
    e-mail: info@onstream.com;
    Sophisticated Circuits Inc.,
    (425) 485-7979,
    e-mail: sales@sophisticated.com;
    Targus Inc.
    (714) 765-5555, e-mail info@targus.com;
    Torque Systems Inc.,
    (415) 252-5521,
    e-mail: info@torque.com.

    From THE COLE PAPERS, February 2000, Copyright © 2000, All Rights Reserved.

  • Top | ColeGroup.com | Consulting | Cole Papers | NewsInc. | Cole's Store | Miscellanea | Search
    Copyright © 1990-2012, The Cole Group. All Rights Reserved. Contact us.
    Modified date: 07/22/2002, 11:42:38 AM.
    URL: http://www.colepapers.net/tcp.archive/cole_papers_00/TCP_00_02/macworld.html