The Cole Papers

Foresight to send: To easily transmit Quark XPress layouts via ISDN, 4-Sight has created an XTension that's available from a pull-down menu.

Virtual Velox: more progress on the digital ad delivery front

LAS VEGAS -- OK, advertising managers: Open your windows, stick your heads out and yell, "We're digital as hell and we're not going to take repros any more."

A lot of you must be doing it already.

Fueled by the Bigfoot advances of Associated Press's AdSEND and a smorgasbord of like-minded companies, electronic ad delivery is getting so fast, easy and popular that the repro -- otherwise known as a Velox, or camera-ready copy -- is becoming an endangered species.

Ad delivery may be one of the few places in 1990s life where paper really is giving way to digits. And the change is about as subtle as a tsunami.

Many companies have sprung up and are profiting -- Advertising Communications International Inc. of Cambridge, Mass., recently was profiled in these pages (see The Cole Papers, April 1996). Others, such as the late AD/SAT, which pioneered the form, have disappeared in the undertow.

Here are some ad transmission companies we saw bobbing among the swells here at NEXPO '96:

Associated Press AdSEND
The 800-pound gorilla of electronic ad delivery is only two years old and is growing like a weed.

Why? Partly because it's AP, which can put its system in 1100 newspapers (at no charge), lure 386 advertisers to send ads at $4 to $38 a pop, and process 40,000 to 50,000 ads a month (with a target of 100,000 a month by the end of this year).

To do it, AP takes in ads from advertisers and sends them via its own satellite network to papers, where they arrive as platform-independent Adobe Acrobat portable document format (PDF) files.

Once on the newspaper's AdSEND server, a human being intervenes, opening each ad in Acrobat, filling out the billing information either on paper or electronically, and converting the PDF file into Encapsulated PostScript (EPS) so it can be paginated or output.

No problem, right? Wrong:

  • You can't not do the file conversion, because PDF doesn't know how to output to a typesetter yet.

  • AP is only now looking at scripting that might enable you to batch-process a folder full of PDF files automatically.

  • Even if you can do the file conversion, you need to do the paperwork by hand.

  • A four-color ad requires four PDF files.

  • PDF is open to questions about how well it carries finely wrought nuances in color, screens and other detail. If you accept the fact that you're losing a little data with each conversion, then you might be concerned that you need to convert once to get a file into PDF form and convert again to get it into a printable form.

    "Acrobat is evolving software," admits Larry Greybill, AdSEND project manager. "But what we see we like. It's relatively easy to work with -- it allows embedding of fonts and high data compression, so at this point PDF is the best solution."

    Still on Greybill's wish list are color management capabilities and the ability to be output directly to film or plate without the format translation.

    Greybill may get some of his other wishes in Adobe Acrobat 3.0. Expected next month, 3.0 should make it possible to store all four colors in one PDF file, and carry open pre-press interface (OPI) comments and other imaging data. And, the next generation of Adobe PostScript raster image processors (RIPs) will image PDF files as well as raw PostScript.

    Does PDF have legs to become more than an AP standard? Greybill said he's optimistically waiting: "I think Version 3.0 will tell us."

    Digiflex
    When it comes to massaging ads before they get sent to the newspaper, Digiflex sees itself as a masseuse and the rest of the field as vibrating beds in some cheap motel.

    "We're not an electronic FedEx," declares Harry Dahl, senior vice president of this division of Autologic Information International of Thousand Oaks, Calif. "We're trying to automate production flow."

    As opposed to the AP "store and forward" method, in which all ads are reduced to the least common denominator of PDF format, stored on a server and transmitted via satellite, Digiflex heavily customizes ads to newspapers' specifications before transmission.

    "We don't force the paper into a single format," Dahl said. "We ask the paper, 'What do you want?'"

    About half his customers want PostScript files and half want EPS. When left up to the customer, few papers want PDF, Dahl claims.

    The customization doesn't stop there. Each ad is delivered cropped and sized exactly, ready to strip into the page. If you're a national advertiser who needs local tags inserted at the bottom of the ad, Digiflex can do that, too.

    Naturally, there's no free lunch. "We do charge more" for all the custom work, Dahl said. That can be as much as $75 for a "rush" ad charged to the advertiser, with a fee of perhaps $8 to newspapers.

    And being a custom house means you don't flip as many burgers as McDonald's: Where AP may do 40,000 to 50,000 ads a month, Digiflex may handle a thousand.

    Television sweeps advertising, which depends on individualized channel numbers and call letters for each station, is a huge part of DigiFlex's business, accounting for up to 5000 ads a month.

    B-Linked Inc.
    To rolf our massage analogy over the pain threshold, B-Linked said, "Heck, why are you shoving quarters into that vibrating bed? Here's a kit to build your own."

    New York-based B-Linked supplies the hardware for about $10,000; you supply a phone or ISDN line, and open your own high-speed bulletin board based on the well-regarded, cross-platform First Class. Advertisers dial up, send their ads, get confirmation and log off.

    "AdSEND and the others are middlemen," said Todd Melet, B-Linked's president. "Middlemen cost money and time."

    B-Linked's system is the digital equivalent of two cans and a string, and simple may be better in some situations -- if you have a giant advertiser who has a history of producing ads that you don't have to rework, for example.

    You also don't have the hassle of converting from PDF as you do with AdSEND. On the other hand, you don't have somebody in New York or Los Angeles to hold your hand and listen while you explain your deadline problems.

    Hey! If you're going to drive a stick shift, accept the fact that sometimes you're going to burn up the clutch.

    4-Sight L.C.
    Taking the B-Linked philosophy a step further is 4-Sight.

    This West Des Moines, Iowa, firm (which is allied with CE Software, of QuickKeys and QuickMail fame; they distribute fax products together), is a U.S. beachhead established by 4-Sight International, a fast-growing British telecommunications software company of the same name.

    The American 4-Sight, well hidden on the NEXPO floor, has one communications product for sale right now: ISDN Manager, a translation engine for disparate ISDN equipment.

    "The problem," said U.S. President Lyndon Stickley, "is that all over Europe, there is a range of different PCs and Macs, and each country has a different flavor of ISDN card."

    Before, you had to have the same hardware at each end to get a good ISDN connection -- great if you have standards, a major hassle if you don't. 4-Sight wrote software embedding the communications protocols used by 28 ISDN cards, which means every ISDN modem is able to talk with any other.

    To accompany this communications prowess, 4-Sight has written a Quark XPress XTension that sends files from the desktop -- a scary thought for those who value other sets of eyes on a project, a joy to harried artists who just want to zap files out of the office and be done with it.

    The same thing has been done with an Adobe Acrobat plug-in, Stickley said.

    But the icing on this digital cake will come in September at Seybold San Francisco, claims Stickley, where the company will launch ADS (Artwork Delivery System) in the U.S. market. ADS will attach a header to ads that should be able to tell other computers where the ad belongs on a server or in the innards of a pagination system.

    This combination of ad management software and telecommunications muscle may be the first of what becomes serious competition for the "store-and-forward" systems that lately have mesmerized the pre-press world.

    Vaporware, it's not. Developed in England by 4-Sight and Associated Newspapers, ADS is used throughout the United Kingdom, Europe, South Africa and Australia.

    Stickley claims the "resources" haven't been there to market it in the United States until now. That all will change, he said, this autumn.

    Future enhancements could attach some kind of automatic pre-flight check of PostScript before the ad gets out of the building and onto the ISDN line.

    Mission Critical Technologies Inc.
    Six years ago, Mission Critical rolled out AdFAX, an automated solution to chip away at the mountain of faxed-in classified ads that get dumped on a newspaper every day.

    AdFAX intercepts the fax, runs it through optical character recognition software, and ultimately displays the product on a screen for an operator to check before the ad is sent into a standard classified ad system.

    But direct transmission from the high-volume advertiser (such as a real estate broker or employment agency) takes the fax out of the picture -- and along with it the inevitable OCR errors that require the operator.

    That's the premise behind the Concord, Mass., company's Adfast, the direct entry software used by 200 newspapers, and a couple of new products:

  • Adfast.com, which works through a World-Wide Web browser for "transient" classified ads (hey, you with the bike for sale -- that's you, ya bum). Transient customers place ads only occasionally, and for them Adfast would be overkill. But a web page with the Adfast.com software gets more ads in more accurately -- a big plus for the hot local newspaper web site craze.

  • AdFast/Images will allow you to send in a picture, either with AdFast or AdFast.com products, for inclusion in the classified ad. The primary market would be the aforementioned real estate agents, but there's no reason a newspaper couldn't expand it to any kind of classified ad.

    So polish up that bike, buddy.

    -- John Bryan

    The Associated Press,
    (212) 621-1732;
    Autologic Information International Inc.,
    (805) 498-9611;
    B-Linked Inc.,
    (212) 532-5083;
    4-Sight L.C.,
    (515) 221-3000;
    Mission Critical Technologies,
    (508) 287-0018.

    From THE COLE PAPERS, July 1996, Copyright © 1996, All Rights Reserved.

  • Top | ColeGroup.com | Consulting | Cole Papers | NewsInc. | Cole's Store | Miscellanea | Search
    Copyright © 1990-2012, The Cole Group. All Rights Reserved. Contact us.
    Modified date: 07/11/1996, 2:44:32 AM.
    URL: http://www.colepapers.net/TCP.archive/Cole_Papers_96/TCP_96_07/digitalads.HTML